Quick Answer: Why Did Lily Chose James Over Snape?

Is Hermione Voldemort’s daughter?

Is Hermione Voldemort’s Daughter.

No.

Plus, Hermione Granger has parents and Rowling clearly established both her heritage (she is Muggle-born, unlike Voldemort) and her family..

Why does Snape hate James Potter?

Originally Answered: Why does Snape hate James Potter? Because Snape was jealous of James’ popularity and proficiency at Quidditch, and fear of Lily falling for him, AND Snape was a bully. The result being that it was SNAPE who actually started the feud with Potter.

Did Snape love Lily or obsessed?

If we take this quote as foreshadowing what we would learn about Snape in book 7, it’s clear he was both obsessed with and in love with Lily. He loved her initially, probably more than James ever did, but he wasn’t able to let her go, therefore his love became a terrible obsession.

Was Lily Potter an Animagus?

It’s well established that Harry’s parents, Lily and James Potter, had doe and stag Patronuses respectively. … Given that James’ Animagus form was a stag, and that his Patronus was obviously affected by that, the conclusion is that Lily’s Patronus is a doe because she fell in love with him.

Who loved Lily more Snape or James?

Who loved Lily Potter more, her husband, James Potter or her childhood friend, Severus Snape? Probably Severus, but really, it is hard to quantify. It also doesn’t really matter; Lily loved James more and that’s ultimately why the paths between the three diverged. … “Once James had deflated his head a bit,” said Sirius.

Is Neville really the chosen one?

Both Harry and Neville were chosen by the prophecy but, in the end, when it comes down to it Voldemort chose Harry over Neville and gave Harry his scar. … Neville might not have been the Chosen One but he is every bit as brave as Harry Potter was and he continued to prove that to readers all throughout the series.

Why did the Marauders hate Snape?

They had legitimate reasons to dislike Snape (outside of Snape being a loner with greasy hair), and Snape had legitimate reasons to dislike the Marauders, the problem was that the Marauders were four on one which is always going to be unfair as hell and wrong and they went way too far in their anger.

Does Snape hate Wormtail?

Snape likely hates Wormtail, but since both men are Death Eaters they have to work together, and it’s likely that Snape didn’t know for a very long time that it was Wormtail who gave away the location of the Potters.

Did Snape love Harry Potter?

Snape according to J.K. Rowling did have some affections towards harry if it was as strong as love we do not know, but he did start protecting harry only for lily’s sake but by the end truly came to like and admire harry.

Who betrayed James and Lily Potter?

Peter PettigrewHowever, they all learned the truth later, when Peter Pettigrew was exposed by Sirius Black and Remus Lupin; “Scabbers” was Peter Pettigrew, the wizard who betrayed James and Lily Potter to Lord Voldemort.

Why is Snape obsessed with Lily?

11 Snape Only Cared About Lily Because She Was Nice To Him Instead, his supposed love came about because Lily was the only person who would be nice to the strange boy.

How did Lily feel about Snape?

No, Lily never loved Snape, and he only has himself to blame for losing her friendship. Yes Lily potter had a small crush on Snape when she was younger. James potter was Lily’s friend and he liked her. But when the James and Snape started fighting Lily took James side.

Did James Potter regret bullying Snape?

When he was about 16, when the girl he liked shouted at him for picking on Severus, we know what he did. He certainly didn’t have a chance to, having died so young. … “Oh, Harry, James actually regretted bullying Snape a lot. He always wanted to apologize.”

Did Snape call Lily a Mudblood?

Severus Snape The two became friends when he started telling her about the wizarding world, being excited of attending Hogwarts together. … When Snape called Lily a “filthy Mudblood” in a fit of anger and humiliation when she defended him from his bullies (including James and Sirius), it was the last straw for Lily.

Did Lily Potter know Snape loved her?

Lily has been portrayed as an intelligent and kind woman. She was one of the best witches in her year at Hogwarts. A combination of theses qualities may lead us to conclude that she must be aware of Snape’s love for her but wanted to save him the embarrassment and pain and never acknowledged his feelings.

What happened to Lily and James Potter?

James and Lily Potter were a married couple and the parents of the famous Harry Potter. They were both Gryffindor students at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry and members of the Order of the Phoenix. They were both murdered by Lord Voldemort on Hallowe’en in 1981, while trying to protect their infant son.

Why was Voldemort so evil?

Voldemort went to levels of evil that his family probably would not. He is evil because he chose to be. So for those of us who may not have the family that we have always wanted, remember Sirius who chose to turn away from his family’s discriminatory practices.

Why did James Potter pick on Snape?

Despite not remembering his parents, Harry held them in high esteem. This faltered slightly where his father was concerned. He learned that James had been something of a bully in his youth, witnessing a memory of Snape’s, in which James and Sirius picked on and humiliated Snape simply because they were bored.

Why were Lily and James marked for death?

Voldemort killed James and Lily Potter because they wanted to kill Harry. He wanted to kill Harry because of a prophecy that told him that Harry was a threat to him. … After Voldemort killed him, Lily did everything to defend Harry and in the end sacrificed herself for him.

Did Lily ever forgive Snape?

No, she didn’t. Snape was a Death Eater until the moment Lily became Voldemort’s target. Lily wouldn’t have forgiven someone who was part of a group whose main goal was to enslaved people like her.

Did James Potter ever apologize to Snape?

During school, James was probably firmly convinced that Severus “deserved” what he got. As he matured as with age after school, he could have been not proud of it like Sirius. But he never apologized. … The only person who did ever apologise after Snape’s worst memory was Severus.